Skip to main content

Was It Really A Failure? (Read to the end to find out)

This year, Mrs. Haynes and I started a Blazer Builders Jr. First Lego League with a small group of third grade builders.  We were excited to start this new challenge.  We started the session after the holiday break and just finished up this afternoon.  We had weekly plans set, a timeline, and an event we were going to attend with our project.  In the end, it didn't work out quite as we had planned. When I look back at my blog it looks as if everything always works perfectly the first time in our library...so not the case.  I have had a hard time with the league not going as planned.  But when I really think about it, I need to live by what I tell my kids each day..."If you haven't failed, you haven't tried!  Things are not always going to work the first time, you may need to try again.  Every problem has a solution, it just may not be the one you planned on."

Where did it go wrong?  Well, it took us way too long to select our topic and successfully research it. We had a hard time making decisions as a group.  We struggled with the motor and getting it to do what we really wanted.  We didn't have enough work time before the school day.  We would just get things moving and the bell would ring to start the day.

Today as we wrapped up Blazer Builder's for the year, Mrs. Haynes and I were a bit defeated as the kids came in.  We felt that we had failed the kids since we had not finished our project nor made it to a Jr. FLL Exposition.  

When we reflected with the kids, they had a totally different opinion of the experience...

One builder said that it was ok that they didn't finish, they had enjoyed the journey. 
Another said that they had gotten to know new friends.  
Another said that they had learned from mistakes.  
They had learned to compromise.
They learned to give up on something that wasn't working.
They learned to work as a team. 
They learned working with a team makes the work go faster.

When asked what they would change, they suggested...
It would have been helpful to have more motors to work with.
They would have liked longer work times.
They would have liked to have met more times.
They suggested that we add more people on the team to divide up the work.

So, was our experience a failure?  NO!

Our group persevered.  Our group learned to compromise.  Group members learned to listen to other's ideas.  Quiet group members became leaders with great ideas.  Strengths started to shine through.  Students progressively failed.  

Where do we go from here?
Mrs. Haynes and I have decided not to continue this club next year.  We always felt bad that only 8 kids had the chance to participate.  Next year, more kids will get an opportunity to program and learn with the Lego WeDo robotics construction sets within the library program, not as a club.  We will also work with programming Lego Mindstorm EV3 robots.  We will try this and see if it works better for us and the kids.  If not, we will problem-solve that too!



Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Kindergarten Builders and Problem-Solvers

Mission:  Using the supplies provided, build a contraption to help the Little Red Hen carry flour. Supplies:  TinkerToys, Yarn, Bucket, 5 lb Bag of Flour Focus:  Creativity, Collaboration, Critical Thinking, Communication, and Fun



The Power of A Book

I recently finished the book, Appleblossom The Possum by Holly Goldberg Sloan (the author of Counting by 7's)  Let me start by saying I will read anything that H. G. Sloan writes.  What an amazing author!  Appleblossom is the sweetest little possum you ever did read about and she totally changed my feelings about possums.  They just don't seem quite so nasty anymore:).  Just look at that cute little possum waving to you on the cover below.  She was drawn by Holly Goldberg Sloan's husband, Gary A. Rosen.

I started reading this book on Monday and found myself headed back to school tonight (Wednesday) after dinner so I could find out what happened to sweet little Appleblossom in the "monster's house."  I have always thought that I didn't enjoy fictional animal books.  I may be the only person in the world who doesn't like Charlotte's Web.  I am beginning to wonder if it is because of the sadness I felt as a little girl when I read about Charlotte…

Fourth Grade Makers: Catapults

For the past couple of years, my 4th graders have started the year with a catapult inquiry project. Each time we work through this unit, I learn something new to improve my students learning.  This year we focused more on planning our ideas and building prototypes (they really just want to go in the MakerSpace and begin making) but we really talked about the benefit of planning.  Using the Launch Cycle Design Model, we are working through the steps to help us build a successful catapult.
We looked at the plans for our newest school addition to reinforce why the planning process is so important and the details that are required for a successful project.



The planning and design process was taken very seriously!

Working in the MakerSpace during the planning process to see what materials are available for their builds.  

A prototype and the plan!

This year I am being a stickler about requiring the kids to build from their plan and not veer off course.  Some tweaks may be necessary but they nee…